How do I find out if people will actually pay for my product?

By Bonaventure Ogeto, Founder and CEO, Mctaba Labs
Published

The short answer

You find out by asking for money, not opinions. Make a real offer to people who have the problem: a price, a delivery date, and a refundable deposit on M-Pesa. Count payments, not promises. If fewer people pay than the pass mark you set beforehand, change the price, the promise or the buyer and run the offer again.

Ask twenty people "would you pay KES 500 a month for this?" and most will say yes. Send the same twenty a Till number and a deadline, and far fewer will pay. The gap between those two numbers is the whole subject of this article.

You do not close that gap by asking better survey questions. You close it by putting a real offer in front of real buyers and counting what arrives on your phone.

Why is "would you pay for this?" the wrong question?

Because answering it is free. The person loses nothing by saying yes and avoids an awkward moment. They are also guessing about a future version of themselves, with a future budget, looking at a product they cannot picture.

Asking "how much would you pay?" is worse. People name a low number to be safe, or a high one to be kind. Neither is a price.

The only reliable signal is a commitment that costs the buyer something today. Opinions from other people, about other products, in other markets do not transfer either. You need your own evidence, from your own customers, for your own offer.

What counts as proof that people will pay?

Think of it as a ladder. Each rung is stronger evidence than the one below, and each costs the customer a little more.

Rung What the customer does How much to trust it
1 Says "I would pay for that" Not at all
2 Asks about price and delivery without being prompted A little
3 Joins a waiting list with a phone number A little more
4 Introduces you to another buyer or to the person who signs Moderately
5 Pays a refundable deposit Strongly
6 Pays the full price for a version you deliver by hand Very strongly
7 Pays a second time This is the real proof

It is tempting to stop at rung 1 or 3 and call it validation. Aim for rung 5 before you commission a build, and get to rung 7 as early as you can, because a second payment means the product did its job.

How do I make an offer for something that does not exist yet?

Be specific and be honest. A pre-sale offer has five parts.

  1. The result, in the customer's words. Not features. What changes for them.
  2. The price, as one number, with the period.
  3. The date they will have it.
  4. The deposit that holds their place, and how to pay it.
  5. The refund promise if you miss the date.

Here is a template. The example is a stock tracking tool for hardware shops, and the numbers are illustrative.

Hello Mr Wafula. When we spoke you said you only discover cement and iron sheets are running low when a customer asks for them. I am setting up a service that sends you a WhatsApp message each morning showing what is below your reorder level, based on your daily sales. It starts on 1 February and costs KES 2,500 a month. I am taking the first ten shops in Eldoret. KES 2,500 to Till 000000 holds your place and covers the first month. It is not built yet. If it is not running in your shop by 1 February, I refund you the same day. Shall I put you down?

Notice what the message does not do. It does not ask what he thinks. It does not list features. It ends with a question that can only be answered yes, no, or with an objection, and all three are useful.

How do I find the right price?

Do not ask. Test three prices on three separate groups.

Start from what the problem costs the customer. If running out of fast-moving stock loses a shop roughly KES 20,000 of sales a month, a price of a few thousand shillings is easy to justify, and a price of KES 15,000 is not. Pick a low, a middle and a high price inside the range that makes sense.

Then split your list. Say you have thirty hardware shop owners who all described the problem. Send ten the offer at KES 1,500, ten at KES 2,500 and ten at KES 4,000. Keep everything else in the message identical. Where you can, split the groups by area or by trade so that neighbours are not quoted different prices.

A tally might look like this. The figures are made up to show the method.

Price per month Offers sent Deposits paid Monthly income if all stay
KES 1,500 10 5 KES 7,500
KES 2,500 10 4 KES 10,000
KES 4,000 10 1 KES 4,000

In this illustration the middle price wins. It loses only one buyer compared with the cheap price and earns more. The high price tells you where the ceiling is. Ten per group is a small sample, so treat the result as a direction and confirm it with the next thirty.

One caution on fairness. If neighbours compare notes and find different prices, honour the lowest for everyone in the test. You were buying information, and that is a fair cost.

How many people need to pay before I believe it?

Decide before you send anything, and write it down. There is no universal conversion rate to compare yourself with, because it depends on the price, the buyer and how well they know you.

A workable way to set the mark: work out how many paying customers would make the first version worth building, then ask what share of your warm list that is. If you need ten paying shops to cover the cost of running the service, and you have thirty owners who told you about the problem in person, your pass mark is ten of thirty. If three pay, you have not passed, however encouraging the conversations were.

Give the test a closing date as well. A deposit that arrives "sometime" is not a deposit. Seven days is enough for a decision of this size.

What do the objections really mean?

Buyers here are careful about paying before they see something, and with good reason. An objection is often not a no. It tells you which part of the offer is weak.

What they say What it usually means What to do
"Let me see it first" They do not trust that it will arrive Deliver the result by hand for one week, then ask again
"It is expensive" The cost of the problem is not clear to them, or it is small Work out the monthly cost of the problem with them. If it is small, this is not your buyer
"Let me think about it" The problem is not urgent Ask what would have to happen for it to become urgent
"Send me the details" A polite exit Send two lines and a date you will call. Count it as a no until money moves
"I need to ask my partner" You are not talking to the person who decides Ask to meet both together
"I will pay at month end" Real cash flow timing Agree a date and follow up on that day

"Let me see it first" deserves the most attention, because you will hear it often and it is the easiest to fix. Running the service by hand for a week costs you evenings, not money, and turns a stranger's promise into something the customer has watched work.

What if my buyer is a business or an institution?

Schools, saccos, clinics and companies rarely pay deposits from a phone. Their version of a deposit is paperwork with a name on it.

In rising order of strength: an email from the decision maker agreeing to a pilot at a stated price, a signed letter of intent, a local purchase order, and a paid pilot invoice. Ask for the strongest one the organisation can give.

Find out early who signs and how long payment takes. An enthusiastic head teacher who cannot spend without the board is at rung 4 on the ladder, not rung 5. And price the pilot. A free pilot proves they will accept a gift. A pilot at even a reduced fee proves there is a budget line for you.

What does the result mean for the product I build?

If people paid, they have written your first specification. The result you promised in the offer is the one job the first version must do. The price that won is the price the system must bill. The way they paid, whether a Till, a Paybill or an invoice, is the payment method to build in first. Everything else can wait until those customers ask for it.

If people did not pay, you have saved the cost of the build and kept the list. Change one thing at a time: the price, then the promise, then the buyer. Each new round takes a week.

Either way, keep the money honest. Record every deposit against a name, keep it apart from your personal spending, deliver on the date, and refund without argument if you cannot. The customers who trusted you before the product existed are the ones most likely to recommend you, if you keep your word.

Key takeaways

  • What people say they would pay and what they pay are different numbers. Only measure the second.
  • A real offer has five parts, which are the result, the price, the date, the deposit and the refund promise.
  • Test three prices with three separate groups instead of asking anyone what they would pay.
  • Write your pass mark down before you send the first message.
  • Treat each objection as information about the offer, not as a rejection of you.
  • For business buyers, a purchase order or a paid pilot replaces the deposit.

Frequently asked questions

How much deposit should I ask for?
Enough that the person has to think before sending it, and small enough that a refund is easy for you. For a monthly product, one month's price is a sensible deposit and can count as the first month. For a larger one-off purchase, a tenth to a fifth of the price shows real intent.
Can I test willingness to pay with a free trial instead?
A free trial tests whether people will try something, which is a much lower bar. Many people use a free tool happily and leave the day it asks for money. If you want to offer a trial, take the payment details or a commitment fee first, so that paying is the default at the end.
What if nobody pays the deposit?
Then you have learned the most valuable thing you could learn at this stage, and it cost you a week. Go back to two or three of the people who declined and ask what would have made them say yes. The answer usually points to the price, the trust gap, or a problem that is not painful enough.
Do I need a registered business to take pre-sale payments?
You can run a small test with a handful of people who know they are paying an individual for something not yet built. Once the test passes and you plan to take payments from the public, set the business up properly and get advice on tax and consumer obligations before you scale it.

Sources

  1. The Mom Test: How to Talk to Customers and Learn If Your Business Is a Good Idea When Everyone Is Lying to You, Rob Fitzpatrick (book, 2013). Checked on 19 November 2026.
  2. The Right It: Why So Many Ideas Fail and How to Make Sure Yours Succeed, Alberto Savoia (book, 2019). Checked on 19 November 2026.